When I started couponing last year, the answer to your question was "B", but the policy changed sometime in the past year. I believe the correct answer is "A" now, although I have not personally verified it at the store. I buy very few of those multipack items at BJ's now because I've found if you match up coupons and sales, most things are cheaper elsewhere. I pretty much only buy dairy, bread, some meat, and my printer cartridges there now. The ironic thing is that I started couponing after I bought CouponMom's book at BJ's. Now I buy very little there.